What Does an ACL Surgery Scar Look Like?
An ACL surgery scar usually consists of two to four small keyhole marks (0.5 to 1 cm each) around the front and sides of your knee joint. Depending on the graft type, you may also have a larger incision where the surgeon removes tendon tissue for ACL reconstruction. Initially, these marks appear red, pink, or purple and slightly raised. However, most scars gradually flatten and fade into thin, pale lines within 6 to 12 months.
At Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, our orthopedic surgeons use minimally invasive arthroscopic techniques (small incisions and a tiny camera) to reduce tissue damage and limit visible scarring. During the procedure, our surgeons carefully place incisions to protect the surrounding tissues and support proper healing. We also provide personalized wound care instructions and rehabilitation plans to reduce the risk of complications. Call 855-321-6784 to book an appointment for expert ACL surgery and recovery care.

How Will Your Knee Look After ACL Surgery?
Your operated knee will initially appear swollen, bruised, and covered with small surgical incision marks. You may also notice a larger cut if your surgeon removes a tendon graft during ACL reconstruction. As your body’s healing process progresses, the swelling decreases, and the incision marks gradually fade.
Here are the key physical changes you can expect at each stage of recovery:
1. Initial Knee Appearance (Days 0–3)
During the first three days, your knee usually appears swollen, with small arthroscopic cuts around the front of the joint. If your surgeon uses your own tendon for the graft, you may also notice a longer incision near the kneecap or inner leg. These cuts often have stitches, surgical glue, or adhesive strips beneath protective dressings. At this stage, the surrounding skin may appear red or bruised as your body begins to heal properly.
You may also notice the following early changes around your operated knee:
- Swelling: Your knee appears larger and puffy due to fluid accumulation around the surgical area.
- Bruising: Purple or blue discoloration may extend toward your shin, calf, or ankle.
- Brace and Dressings: A protective bandage covers the incisions, while your surgeon may recommend a knee brace and crutches.
2. Early Recovery (Weeks 1–4)
Over the first few weeks, swelling gradually decreases, although your knee may still appear slightly larger than the other side. As the bruises fade, the small incision marks become more visible and may appear pink or reddish.
During this period, scar tissue also begins to form around the surgical incisions as your body repairs the damaged tissues. You may also notice thigh muscle weakness or reduced muscle size due to limited activity. With early movement and rehabilitation, you can gradually restore muscle strength and improve knee mobility.
3. Long-Term Changes (Months 2–12+)
By the second month, your knee often looks less swollen as the surgical wounds heal and the surrounding tissues recover. Over the following months, scar formation progresses, and the incision marks gradually flatten into pale or silvery lines.
With regular exercise, you gradually rebuild muscle strength, and your operated leg begins to look more like the healthy leg. However, mild joint thickening or occasional swelling may persist for several months as the deeper tissues continue to heal.
Where Will You Have Scars After ACL Surgery?
You will usually have two to four small incision marks around the front and sides of your knee, where the surgeon inserts a camera and surgical instruments. If your surgeon uses a tendon from your own body, you will also have a larger scar near the kneecap or inner knee, depending on the graft type.
However, the exact incision direction and placement vary based on the surgical technique and prior injury. Your surgeon may also adjust the incision sites if you need a meniscus (knee cartilage) repair during the same procedure.
How Big Are the Incision Scars on Your Knee?
Most ACL surgeries result in two to four small incision marks, each about 0.5 to 1 cm long. Surgeons make these tiny incisions around the knee joint to insert an arthroscope (a small camera) and surgical instruments. However, if your surgeon uses a tendon from your own body, you may have a longer scar at the graft-harvest site. The size of this additional incision depends on the type of graft your surgeon selects, such as:
- Patellar Tendon Graft: The incision usually measures 3 to 5 cm along the front of your knee.
- Hamstring Tendon Graft: Surgeons typically create a 3- to 5-cm incision on the inner side of your knee, just below the joint.
- Quadriceps Tendon Graft: A small incision, usually 2 to 4 cm long, sits above your kneecap, depending on the surgical technique.
- Allograft (Donor Tissue): Since the surgeon uses donor tissue, you will not have an additional tendon-harvest scar. However, small incisions are still required for graft placement.
A study published in the Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy journal compared surgical scars among 90 patients undergoing ACL reconstruction. Researchers found that quadriceps tendon grafts resulted in an average incision of 2.8 cm, compared with 6.4 cm for patellar tendon grafts. This difference shows that graft selection can affect the length of your surgical scar. However, the final incision size also depends on your surgeon’s technique and individual surgical needs.
Important Note: These measurements are approximate, as graft-harvest techniques and surgical approaches can affect incision length.
Why Do Some Knee Surgery Scars Look Different?
ACL surgical marks vary in appearance based on the graft type, surgical technique, and your body’s natural healing response. For example, a patellar tendon graft often creates a vertical scar over the kneecap. In contrast, hamstring and quadriceps grafts cause marks near the inner knee or above the kneecap.
Similarly, modern arthroscopic techniques use smaller incisions, whereas open surgery or additional procedures may require longer cuts. Beyond the surgical approach, your age, skin type, and genetics also affect the final appearance. Repeated knee movement can stretch the incision area and cause wider marks during recovery.
In some cases, excess collagen (a protein that repairs skin) can produce thick, raised scars, such as a keloid. Additionally, a comparative study published in Arthroscopy examined how incision direction affects scar appearance in 76 patients who underwent ACL reconstruction. Researchers compared horizontal and vertical incisions at the tendon-harvest site and reported the following findings:
- Vertical Incisions: 59% of patients experienced nerve-related sensory changes near the surgical cut.
- Horizontal Incisions: 43% of patients experienced similar sensory changes.
- Scar Appearance: Patients with horizontal incisions reported greater satisfaction with the appearance of their scars than those with vertical incisions.
How Long Do ACL Scars Take to Heal?
The small surgical incisions usually close and heal within 2 to 4 weeks after ACL surgery with proper wound care. However, the marks gradually flatten and fade into thin, pale lines over 6 to 12 months. The exact recovery time varies based on several factors, such as your skin type and the risk of infection.
The following factors can also affect how quickly your incisions heal and how noticeable your scars become:
- Diabetes: High blood sugar can slow wound healing and affect scar appearance.
- Genetics: Your inherited healing tendencies can affect scar thickness and texture.
- Age: Younger patients often heal wounds faster, although their scars are not always less noticeable.
What Should Your Knee Scar Look Like After 2 Weeks?
Two weeks after ACL surgery, your small incisions should appear closed, with pink or reddish lines along the surgical sites. These marks may feel slightly firm, raised, or tight as the skin continues to heal. You may also notice yellow, green, or purple bruises and mild swelling around your knee, lower leg, or ankle. However, if you are concerned about increasing redness, warmth, or other symptoms of infection, seek early intervention from your surgeon.
By six months after surgery, you may notice the following changes as your surgical marks continue to heal:
- Fading Color: Red or pink marks gradually turn lighter and may appear pale.
- Flatter Texture: Raised incision marks usually soften and flatten over time.
- Keyhole Marks: Small arthroscopic incisions often become faint and less noticeable.
- Graft Site: Larger incisions may retain some redness or sensitivity for several months.
- Skin Sensitivity: Mild tightness, numbness, or tenderness may persist around the surgical marks.
Will Your ACL Surgery Scar Ever Disappear?
No, your ACL surgery scar will not completely disappear. The marks are permanent because your body forms scar tissue to repair the surgical cuts. However, they gradually flatten and fade into thin, pale lines over time. Although many patients notice significant improvement within 6 to 12 months, skin type and strain on the incision area can affect the final appearance.
Why Does My Knee Surgery Scar Feel Hard or Raised?
Your ACL surgery scar may feel firm, tight, or raised because your body produces collagen (a protein that repairs damaged tissue) during healing. Sometimes, excess collagen forms a thick, firm area called a hypertrophic scar. Although mild firmness is common during recovery, other factors can also affect the scar’s texture, such as:
- Repeated Movement: Frequent knee bending can place strain on healing tissue.
- Deeper Scar Tissue: Tissue beneath the incision may attach to nearby structures.
- Internal Scarring: A cyclops lesion may restrict extension, preventing you from straightening your knee fully.
Is Numbness Around the Surgical Incision Normal?
Yes, mild numbness around your ACL surgical incision is common during recovery. This happens when surgery irritates small sensory nerves near the skin. Swelling or nerve blocks can also temporarily reduce sensation around the knee. In most cases, sensation gradually improves over several months, although some numbness may persist.
In fact, a study published in The Journal of Knee Surgery followed 218 patients after ACL reconstruction. Researchers found that 69.8% reported numbness at six weeks, while 50% reported it at six months. By one year, the percentage had decreased to 42.2%, showing that sensation often improves gradually after surgery.

How Can You Reduce Scarring After ACL Surgery?
You can minimize visible scars and internal scar tissue through proper wound care, gentle movement, and targeted treatments. During the first few weeks, protecting your surgical incisions helps promote skin healing and reduce complications. As your wounds heal, scar treatments and rehabilitation exercises can improve skin flexibility and help you regain knee mobility.
Here is how these steps can support scar healing and reduce stiffness throughout your recovery.
1. Protect Your Surgical Incisions
Proper wound care during the first 2 to 3 weeks reduces irritation and supports healthy skin repair. During this period, keep your incisions clean and dry according to your surgeon’s instructions. Also, avoid scratching scabs or soaking your knee until the wounds heal completely. Once the skin closes, apply SPF 30 or higher sunscreen to protect the scars from UV exposure.
2. Use Silicone Sheets and Topical Treatments
Silicone sheets can improve the appearance of scars after ACL surgery. Once your wounds have completely healed, you can use silicone gels or sheets to soften and flatten raised marks. Other topical treatments may contain vitamin E or onion extract. However, some products may irritate sensitive skin or cause allergic reactions. Therefore, ask your surgeon before applying any new creams or products to your scars.
3. Start Gentle Scar Massage After Wound Closure
Gentle scar massage can improve skin flexibility once your surgical incisions have fully healed. Before you begin, ask your surgeon or rehabilitation specialist to confirm that the scabs have fallen off and the skin has healed. Then, use light circular, side-to-side, and up-and-down movements to loosen the tissue around the scar. Stop the massage if you notice redness, swelling, or painful areas.
4. Follow Rehabilitation Exercises
Rehabilitation exercises help improve knee mobility and reduce stiffness from internal scar tissue. These exercises often begin on the first day after surgery. However, your surgeon may restrict certain movements based on your procedure. Your rehabilitation specialist may recommend the following exercises to restore knee movement:
- Heel Slides: Gently bend and straighten your knee to improve flexibility.
- Quadriceps Sets: Tighten your thigh muscles to restore strength and knee stability.
- Knee Extension: Gently straighten your leg to improve your knee’s range of motion.
When Should You Worry About Your ACL Surgery Scar?
You should contact your surgeon if your incision develops increasing redness, severe pain, or pus. These changes may signal an infection, especially if you also have fever or chills. You should also seek medical attention if the wound opens or the scar becomes unusually thick and raised. Although the reported rate of symptomatic scarring after ACL reconstruction is about 0.34%, persistent symptoms require prompt evaluation.
You should also contact your surgeon if you notice any of the following warning signs:
- Limited Movement: Difficulty bending or fully straightening your knee.
- Persistent Stiffness: Trouble activating your thigh muscles or walking with a straight knee.
- Knee Instability: Your knee buckles or gives way during daily activities.
If you notice unusual scar changes or difficulty walking after ACL surgery, visit Total Ortho Express for prompt orthopedic care. Our medical team can examine your surgical incision and assess your knee movement to identify possible complications. We also provide on-site X-rays, bracing, and splinting when appropriate for your condition. If you need further evaluation, we can arrange a referral to an orthopedic specialist for recovery support.
Schedule a Consultation at Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine for Persistent Knee Scar Pain!
You may worry about whether your ACL surgery scars will fade or become permanent marks on your knee. If your incisions look red, raised, or uneven, you may wonder whether they are healing normally. You may also worry about numbness, stiffness, or a noticeable scar that affects your confidence in how your knee looks.
At Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, our orthopedic surgeons assess your knee and use surgical techniques that reduce tissue damage. After surgery, we monitor your healing through regular follow-up visits. During these visits, our specialists examine your scars and adjust your care plan as needed. We also provide a detailed post-operative ACL reconstruction guide covering wound care, dressing changes, brace use, and early knee exercises. Call 855-321-6784 or visit one of our New York or New Jersey locations to schedule an ACL surgical consultation.
FAQs
Why Does My ACL Scar Pull When I Straighten My Leg?
Your ACL scar may pull when you straighten your leg because the skin and deeper tissues stretch as your knee extends. If scar tissue attaches to deeper structures near the tibia or femur, it can cause tightness or a tugging sensation. In some cases, internal scar tissue or a cyclops lesion (a small scar tissue nodule) can also restrict your straight leg movement.
Can I Shower With My Knee Incisions?
Yes, you can shower after ACL surgery once your surgeon allows it. However, you should keep your incisions dry for the first 48 to 72 hours and use a waterproof cover to protect your dressings. Avoid soaking your knee in a bathtub or pool until your incisions heal, and your surgeon confirms it is safe.
Can I Get a Tattoo Over My ACL Surgery Scar?
Yes, you can get a tattoo over your ACL surgery scar once it has fully healed and your surgeon approves. Waiting 12 to 18 months is often beneficial, as the scar needs time to flatten and reach full maturity. Tattooing before the scar fully matures can cause skin irritation or uneven ink distribution, especially if the tissue is still raised or sensitive.
Can I Apply Vitamin E Oil to My Knee Scar?
No, dermatologists generally do not recommend vitamin E oil for knee scars because it may irritate the skin. In fact, one clinical study found that vitamin E had no effect or worsened scar appearance in 90% of cases. The same study reported that 33% of patients developed contact dermatitis (an allergic skin reaction).
Why Does My ACL Surgical Scar Hurt When I Kneel?
Your ACL surgical scar may hurt when you kneel because direct pressure compresses sensitive nerves and healing tissues at the front of your knee. This pressure can irritate scar tissue around the incision, especially if your surgeon used a patellar tendon graft. As the tissues heal and sensitivity decreases, kneeling often becomes more comfortable over time.