Blue Cross Blue ShieldWe are happy to share that Total Orthopedics including our Express locations are now accepting BCBS.

We are happy to share that Total Orthopedics including our Express locations are now accepting BCBS.

How Is Pediatric ACL Reconstruction Different?

Pediatric ACL reconstruction uses special surgical techniques to protect a child’s open growth plates (areas of developing bone) near the knee. Unlike adult surgery, these techniques reduce the risk of damage to the knee joint as the child grows. This approach also reduces the risk of limb-length discrepancy (unequal leg lengths) and bone deformities.

At Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, our knee specialists assess your child’s age, growth plate development, and ligament damage before recommending treatment. We use detailed examinations and MRI scans to evaluate the injury and select the most suitable surgical approach. Our team also develops a personalized rehabilitation plan to restore knee strength and stability. Call 855-321-6784 to schedule a consultation and discuss the safest treatment options for your child.

Medical infographic illustrates pediatric ACL reconstruction steps from torn ligament through graft preparation and fixation.

What Is the Difference Between Pediatric and Adult ACL Surgery?

Adult ACL surgery typically uses standard reconstruction techniques to replace the torn ligament with a tendon graft through bone tunnels. In contrast, pediatric surgeons modify these techniques to protect open growth plates near the thigh bone and shin bone. While both procedures aim to restore knee stability, they differ in the following ways:

FactorsAdult ACL SurgeryPediatric ACL Surgery
Graft SelectionPatellar, hamstring, quadriceps, or donor grafts.Own hamstring or quadriceps tendon preferred.
Surgery TimingSurgery may wait with activity restrictions.Earlier surgery may prevent additional damage.
Reinjury RiskGenerally lower risk in older adults.Higher reinjury risk among young athletes.
Growth Plate ProtectionNo growth plate precautions usually necessary.Surgeons protect growth plates during reconstruction.
RehabilitationProgress depends on strength and function.Rehabilitation considers growth and sports demands.

What Are the Different Types of Pediatric ACL Reconstruction?

Surgeons use physeal sparing techniques and all-epiphyseal reconstruction to protect growth plates in younger children. For older adolescents, they may recommend transphyseal reconstruction, which uses carefully planned bone tunnels across the growth plates. Other options, such as iliotibial band autograft reconstruction and combined ligament procedures, provide additional stability.

Here is what each surgical technique does and when surgeons recommend it:

1. Physeal-Sparing or All-Epiphyseal Reconstruction

Surgeons use this technique for younger children who have significant bone growth ahead. An all-epiphyseal ACLR avoids drilling through the open growth plates. Instead, surgeons create tunnels within the ends of the thigh and shin bones to secure the tendon graft. This approach protects normal bone development and reduces the risk of growth-related complications.

2. Transphyseal ACL Reconstruction

Surgeons may recommend partial transphyseal ACL reconstruction for children who have 5–7 years of bone growth remaining. During surgery, the surgeon creates a bone tunnel across one growth plate while avoiding the other. They use soft-tissue grafts and carefully planned tunnel placement to reduce the risk of growth disturbance. This technique restores knee stability while protecting the child’s developing bones.

3. Extra-Articular Iliotibial Band Reconstruction

Surgeons often recommend an iliotibial band autograft for young children with significant future bone growth. During this procedure, the surgeon takes a strip of tissue from the outer thigh to replace the torn ACL. Then they guide this tissue around the thigh bone and across the front of the shin bone without drilling bone tunnels. This technique protects the open growth plates while restoring knee stability.

4. Combined Intra-Articular and Extra-Articular Reconstruction

Surgeons may combine ACL reconstruction with lateral extra-articular tenodesis (a procedure that adds support to the outer knee) for young athletes at high risk of reinjury. The primary graft replaces the torn ligament inside the knee joint. At the same time, the additional procedure strengthens the outer knee structures to reduce excessive rotation. This combined approach may lower the risk of graft failure and recurrent instability after surgery.

Do Children and Adults Need Different ACL Grafts?

Yes, surgeons consider different ACL graft options for children and adults due to skeletal maturity and open growth plates. For adults, surgeons can use autografts (the patient’s own tissue) or allografts (donor tissue), depending on their age, activity level, and knee condition. In contrast, pediatric surgeons generally recommend autografts over allografts for ACL reconstruction.

Surgeons generally avoid donor grafts due to higher failure rates in young patients. Using the child’s own tissue can reduce the risk of graft failure and support restoring knee stability. However, surgeons select the most suitable ACL graft based on the following factors:

  • Patient’s Age: Surgeons consider the child’s age and remaining bone growth when selecting a graft.
  • Activity Level: The child’s sports participation and physical demands guide graft selection.
  • Knee Condition: Surgeons assess ligament damage, knee stability, and associated meniscus or cartilage injuries.

Which ACL Graft Has the Highest Failure Rate in Children?

Allografts (donor tissue) have the highest reported failure rate in pediatric ACL reconstruction. Among autografts (the child’s own tissue), hamstring tendon autografts have higher re-tear rates than patellar and quadriceps tendon grafts. In fact, a systematic review published in JBJS Open Access reported the following ACL graft failure rates in patients aged 19 years or younger:

  • Allograft (Donor Tissue): 25.5% failure rate, the highest among the graft types studied.
  • Hamstring Tendon Autograft: 16.6% failure rate, higher than patellar tendon autografts.
  • Patellar Tendon Autograft: 8.5% failure rate, the lowest among the three graft types compared.

Another systematic review published in the Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine in 2024 analyzed 24 studies involving 2,299 patients aged 18 or younger. Researchers found that quadriceps tendon autografts had the lowest pooled failure rate at 2.7%. In comparison, patellar tendon grafts had a 7.9% failure rate, while hamstring grafts had an 11.8% failure rate. However, the risk of graft rupture also depends on the child’s age, activity level, and remaining bone growth.

Is It Safer to Delay ACL Surgery in Adults Than Children?

Yes, adults with a torn ACL can sometimes delay surgery if they avoid high-risk activities and follow a rehabilitation plan. However, delaying surgery in active children can increase knee instability and the risk of additional injuries. Repeated episodes of knee instability can damage the meniscus and cartilage.

For children, surgeons must balance the risk of growth disturbance against the need to restore knee stability. To assess this risk, they examine the child’s growth plates and determine how much bone growth is left. They also evaluate knee instability and associated pediatric ACL injuries before recommending the appropriate time for surgery.

When Does a Child Need ACL Reconstruction?

A child may need surgery if a torn ACL causes repeated knee instability or damage to other joint structures. Surgeons also recommend reconstruction when young athletes want to return to sports that require sudden turns and quick changes in direction. In fact, a systematic review found that 92% of children and adolescents returned to sports after surgery. However, only 78.6% returned to their pre-injury level of sports performance.

Moreover, the following signs may indicate that your child needs surgical treatment:

  • Complete ACL Tear: The ligament has torn completely and cannot support normal knee stability.
  • Repeated Knee Instability: The knee gives out during walks, runs, or sports.
  • Meniscus or Cartilage Damage: Other knee structures have injuries that may require surgical repair.
  • Failed Nonsurgical Treatment: Rehabilitation and activity restrictions do not restore adequate knee stability.

Can a Child’s ACL Tear Heal Without Surgery?

Yes, mild sprains and some partial pediatric ACL tears can heal without surgery if the knee remains stable. However, complete ACL tears rarely heal on their own and can lead to recurrent knee instability. For children with stable knees, doctors may recommend structured ACL rehabilitation exercises and activity restrictions to support recovery. They also assess the child’s growth plates, activity level, and knee condition to determine if surgical intervention is necessary.

Is There an Ideal Age for ACL Reconstruction in Children?

No, there is no single ideal age for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in children. Instead, surgeons assess the child’s growth plates and remaining skeletal growth to determine the right time for surgery. Delaying ACL surgery until growth is complete can increase knee instability and the risk of meniscus tears and cartilage damage.

  • Younger Children (Ages 8–12): Physeal-sparing techniques protect open growth plates during ACL reconstruction.
  • Growing Adolescents (Ages 13–16): Modified or partial-transphyseal techniques may be suitable based on remaining bone growth.
  • Nearly Mature Teens (Ages 15–17+): Surgeons can use standard ACL reconstruction techniques when growth plates are nearly closed.

Important Note: Age ranges are general guidelines, as the safest surgical approach depends on your child’s bone growth.

What Tests Are Needed Before Pediatric ACL Surgery?

Before surgery, doctors perform physical examinations and imaging tests to confirm anterior cruciate ligament tears in children. These tests assess knee stability and identify damage to the ligaments, meniscus, or cartilage. Doctors also examine the child’s growth plates to plan the safest ACL treatment. During the physical examination, doctors perform the following tests to assess knee stability and identify signs of ligament damage:

  • Lachman Test: Checks for excessive forward movement of the shin bone when the knee is slightly bent.
  • Anterior Drawer Test: Measures forward movement of the shin bone while the knee is bent at 90 degrees.
  • Pivot Shift Test: Checks rotational stability and whether the knee gives out during movement.
  • KT-1000 Arthrometer Test: Uses a measuring device to compare the degree of looseness between the injured and healthy knees.

How Is Tanner Staging Used Before Child ACL Surgery?

Tanner staging assesses pubertal development to estimate skeletal maturity in children with ACL tears. This assessment helps surgeons understand how much growth a child has left before planning surgery. Based on these findings, surgeons select an appropriate ACL treatment technique to protect the child’s growth plates.

Infographic shows five Tanner stages guiding pediatric ACL surgery planning from prepubertal growth through maturity.

How Should You Prepare Your Child for ACL Surgery?

You should discuss your child’s growth plate development and surgical options with a pediatric orthopedic specialist. Before knee surgery, review all medications and supplements with the surgeon and follow the fasting instructions for anesthesia. Your child may also need to bathe with a special antibacterial soap before surgery to reduce the risk of infection.

Moreover, you can prepare your child for surgery and recovery by following these steps:

  • Pre-Surgery Exercises: Practice gentle strengthening exercises, such as quad sets and calf raises, as recommended by the care team.
  • Crutch Training: Teach your child to walk safely with properly fitted crutches.
  • Knee Brace: Arrange a brace fitting and learn how to adjust it if prescribed.
  • Recovery Area: Prepare a comfortable resting space with pillows, ice packs, and essential supplies.
  • School Arrangements: Plan for several days off school and arrange transportation if needed.
  • Recovery Supplies: Prepare loose clothing, prescribed medications, and easy meals.
  • Ride Home: Arrange for a responsible adult to take your child home after surgery.

How Long Is Recovery After Pediatric ACL Surgery?

Recovery after pediatric ACL surgery typically takes 6 to 12 months, depending on the child’s progress and ACL healing. Around 6–7 months after surgery, doctors begin strength and stability testing to assess knee function. However, pediatric patients should not return to high-impact or pivoting sports for at least 9 months after surgery. Even after this period, returning to play sports depends on passing strength, balance, and movement tests.

Here are the key stages of pediatric ACL surgery recovery, from the first day after surgery to returning to sports:

  • Day of Surgery: Most children return home the same day after surgery.
  • First Week: Children often miss about five school days and begin rehabilitation exercises within 5–7 days.
  • First Month: Many children regain normal walking without crutches as knee strength improves.
  • 3–4 Months: Light jogging may begin if knee strength meets recovery goals.
  • 6–9 Months: Strength, balance, and movement testing assess readiness for more demanding activities.
  • 9–12 Months: Return to competitive sports may begin after medical clearance and successful functional testing.

Important Note: Recovery varies for each child, and returning to sports requires successful functional testing and surgeon clearance.

Is Pediatric ACL Reconstruction Safe and Successful?

Yes, pediatric ACL reconstruction is generally safe and successful when surgeons use techniques that protect the child’s open growth plates. These specialized techniques reduce the risk of growth-related complications while restoring stability to the injured knee. With proper rehabilitation, most pediatric and adolescent patients can return to sports and daily activities.

However, clinical outcomes depend on the child’s age, surgical technique, and recovery progress. A 2020 study published in Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy followed 20 children aged 6–16 who underwent ACL repair with an internal brace. After two years, researchers reported no treatment failures, complications, or growth disturbances.

Is ACL Reinjury More Common in Children Than Adults?

Yes, children and adolescents face a higher risk of another ACL injury after surgery than older adults. This risk increases when adolescent patients return to demanding sports too early. At this stage, they may not have regained enough knee strength and control to prevent another injury. In contrast, adults who participate in lower-impact activities generally have fewer risk factors for reinjury.

In fact, a study published in the Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine compared 5,479 patients after ACL reconstruction. Over five years, 18% of patients under 20 required revision surgery. In comparison, the revision rate was 9.2% among adults aged 20–29. This rate was even lower at 7.1% among adults aged 30–39.

Can ACL Repair Affect a Child’s Bone Growth?

Yes, ACL surgery can affect a child’s bone growth if surgical techniques damage the open growth plates. These plates regulate bone development and contribute significantly to lower-limb growth. However, modern techniques such as physeal-sparing ACL reconstruction protect these areas and reduce the risk of growth disturbances.

Damage to the growth plates during surgery can cause the following complications:

  • Limb Length Discrepancy: One leg becomes longer or shorter than the other.
  • Angular Deformities: The leg develops a knock-knee or bow-legged shape.
  • Growth Arrest: Part of the bone stops growing too early.
  • Bone Overgrowth: The affected bone grows faster than expected.

A study published in Current Reviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine reported that growth plates around the knee contribute approximately 65% of lower-limb growth. Damage to these plates can affect normal bone development after surgery. In fact, another study reported a 14.8% growth disturbance rate among 27 children who underwent all-epiphyseal ACL reconstruction.

Schedule a Pediatric ACL Consultation at Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine!

If your child has a torn ACL, you may worry about the risks of surgery while their bones are still growing. Delaying treatment can increase knee instability and the risk of further damage. However, surgery also requires careful planning to protect your child’s growth plates. For this reason, your child’s treatment plan must address both knee stability and normal bone development.

At Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, our orthopedic specialists assess your child’s ACL injury, growth plates, and knee stability to recommend the most appropriate treatment. We develop personalized surgical and rehabilitation plans to protect bone development and support a safe return to daily activities and sports. We also accept major insurance plans to support access to specialized orthopedic care. Call 855-321-6784 or visit our New York or New Jersey locations to schedule your child’s ACL consultation.

FAQs

Is Pediatric ACL Surgery Painful?

Yes, children can experience significant pain after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. This discomfort can continue for up to two weeks as the knee heals from surgery. However, prescribed pain medications, ice packs, and gentle rehabilitation exercises can reduce discomfort and support recovery.

Is Bridge-Enhanced ACL Repair Safe for Growing Children?

Yes, bridge-enhanced ACL repair can be a safe option for selected growing children with ACL tears. Unlike traditional ACL reconstruction, this technique repairs the torn ligament without removing a tendon graft or drilling bone tunnels across the growth plates. This approach can also protect bone development in skeletally immature patients.

Can Anterolateral Ligament Reconstruction Prevent ACL Retears?

Yes, anterolateral ligament reconstruction can reduce the risk of another ACL tear when combined with ACL reconstruction. This procedure improves knee stability and protects the ACL graft during twisting movements. As a result, patients may have a lower graft re-rupture rate than those who undergo ACL reconstruction alone.

Will My Child Have Permanent Scars After ACL Surgery?

Yes, your child will have permanent scars after ACL surgery, but they are usually small and thin. Modern surgical techniques use small incisions that reduce visible scarring. Over time, these marks gradually fade and become less noticeable.

Are ACL Injuries More Common in Teenage Girls?

Yes, ACL tears are two to eight times more common in teenage girls than boys who play similar sports. ACL tears are among the most common knee injuries affecting young female athletes. This higher risk may result from differences in muscle strength, landing mechanics, and hormonal changes.

Request Your Appointment Today