Who Is the Best Hip Arthroscopy Surgeon On New York?

Dr. Jarret Boroniec is one of the best hip arthroscopy surgeons in NYC, offering fellowship-trained sports medicine expertise and advanced minimally invasive hip care. He carefully identifies the cause of your symptoms before recommending treatment. His goal is to relieve pain, preserve your natural hip, and help you return to the activities you enjoy. While serving as an assistant team physician for the Rochester Red Wings, Dr. Jarret Boroniec gained valuable experience treating active individuals. Today, he uses that experience to treat his patients at Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine. Call 855-321-6784 to book your consultation in NYC.

What Makes Dr. Jarret Boroniec the Best Hip Arthroscopy Surgeon?

Dr. Jarret Boroniec tailors every treatment recommendation to your hip condition and recovery goals, rather than following a one-size-fits-all approach. He evaluates how your symptoms, lifestyle, and long-term activity goals relate to the underlying hip problem. His experience across sports injuries, joint preservation, and reconstructive orthopedics allows him to evaluate hip pain from multiple perspectives rather than focusing on a single diagnosis.

Based on your diagnosis, he carefully evaluates whether your symptoms are best managed with rehabilitation, injections, hip arthroscopy, or another treatment before recommending surgery. This thoughtful approach helps maximize function while avoiding unnecessary procedures whenever appropriate.

In addition, Dr. Jarret Boroniec graduated magna cum laude from Michigan State University and earned induction into the Sigma Sigma Phi honor society for academic achievement and leadership. He later completed his orthopedic residency across several leading Northwell Health hospitals, where he gained broad experience in joint reconstruction, trauma, and complex orthopedic care.

Other than that, Dr. Jarret Boroniec is an active member of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) and the Arthroscopy Association of North America (AANA). Through these organizations, he stays informed about the latest research, surgical techniques, and treatment guidelines. This helps ensure patients receive care based on current evidence and best practices.

How Can You Evaluate a Surgeon’s Experience?

You should review a surgeon’s specialized training, experience performing hip arthroscopy, and the types of hip conditions they most frequently treat. These factors help you determine whether the surgeon has the right experience for your specific hip condition. You should also ask how they approach diagnosis, treatment planning, and recovery before deciding whether they are the right fit for your care.

Here are some other factors you should review before choosing a hip arthroscopy surgeon:

• Years Performing Hip Arthroscopy: Ask how long the surgeon has been performing hip arthroscopy rather than relying on their total years in orthopedic practice.
• Experience With Complex Cases: Ask whether the surgeon routinely treats conditions such as hip impingement, labral tears, cartilage injuries, and revision hip arthroscopy.
• Complication and Revision Rates: Discuss how often patients require additional surgery or experience complications after hip arthroscopy.
• Use of Advanced Arthroscopic Techniques: Ask whether the surgeon routinely performs modern hip preservation procedures and stays current with evolving surgical techniques.
• Clinical Outcomes: Review available outcome data, including improvements in pain, hip function, return to sports, and patient satisfaction when available.
• Procedure Volume: Find out how many hip arthroscopy procedures the surgeon performs each year, as regular experience can help maintain technical proficiency.

In fact, a study published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine found that patients treated by surgeons with the highest career volumes had significantly lower rates of additional hip surgery than those treated by lower-volume surgeons.

What Credentials Should a Hip Surgeon Have?

You should choose a hip surgeon who is board-certified in orthopedic surgery and has completed fellowship training in sports medicine or hip preservation. Professional memberships, ongoing education, and experience with modern arthroscopic techniques also show a commitment to high standards of patient care.

Our orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Jarret Boroniec, has the following credentials, earned through advanced orthopedic education and specialized training:

• Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.) from Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine.
• Orthopedic Sports Medicine Fellowship at the University of Rochester Medical Center, with advanced training in arthroscopic surgery.
• Orthopedic Surgery Residency at the Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell
• Assistant Team Physician of Rochester Red Wings, Triple-A affiliate of the Washington Nationals.
• Experienced in Both Operative and Nonoperative Orthopedic Care for youth and adult patients.
• Specializes in Arthroscopic and Open Treatment of shoulder, elbow, hip, and knee injuries.

Why Is Fellowship Training Important for Hip Surgery?

Fellowship training provides advanced, hands-on experience beyond orthopedic residency, with a dedicated focus on complex hip conditions and arthroscopic techniques. This additional training helps surgeons manage challenging cases, refine surgical skills, and make well-informed treatment decisions. Fellowship-trained surgeons also have experience with evolving techniques such as postless hip arthroscopy, eliminating the need for a perineal post. As a result, you benefit from care backed by specialized expertise in hip preservation and minimally invasive surgery.

Here is how fellowship training differs from a standard orthopedic residency:

Orthopedic Residency	Fellowship Training
Broad orthopedic training	Advanced hip specialization
General joint procedures	Complex hip arthroscopy
Wide range of injuries	Hip preservation focus
Core surgical skills	Advanced arthroscopic skills
General orthopedic care	Complex hip conditions

What Can You Expect During Your First Visit?

During your first visit, our hip specialist, Dr. Jarret Boroniec, focuses on identifying the exact cause of your hip symptoms before recommending any treatment. He reviews your medical history, performs a detailed physical examination, and evaluates any available imaging to understand how your hip condition is affecting your movement.

In addition, Dr. Jarret Boroniec may ask when your hip pain began, which movements or activities worsen it, and whether it affects your work, exercise, or daily routine. He may also ask about previous injuries, treatments such as rest or injections, current medications, and any prior imaging or surgeries. Your answers help him accurately diagnose your condition and recommend the most appropriate treatment. Once the diagnosis is clear, he explains your treatment options, answers your questions, and helps you choose the approach that best fits your goals and lifestyle.

Does Dr. Jarret Boroniec Offer Non-Surgical Options?

Yes, Dr. Jarret Boroniec offers a range of nonsurgical treatment options for many hip conditions before considering surgery. Depending on your diagnosis, he may recommend activity modification, anti-inflammatory medications, or image-guided injections to relieve pain and improve hip function.

Each non-surgical treatment plays a different role in relieving symptoms and improving hip function, such as:

Activity Modification

Activity modification involves temporarily changing or limiting movements that place excessive stress on your hip joint. Dr. Jarret Boroniec may recommend activity modification if certain activities consistently trigger pain or worsen your symptoms. Instead of stopping all physical activity, he helps you avoid movements that irritate the joint while encouraging safe alternatives. This approach gives inflamed tissues time to recover. Moreover, it can help prevent further irritation while your hip is being monitored or treated. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) also recommends modifying activities that worsen hip symptoms while switching to lower-impact exercises to reduce stress on the joint and improve function.

Anti-Inflammatory Medications

Anti-inflammatory medications can help reduce pain and inflammation caused by many hip conditions. By reducing inflammation, they may make walking, sitting, and other daily activities more comfortable. According to the latest AAOS Clinical Practice Guideline, oral nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have strong evidence supporting their use to reduce pain and improve function in patients with symptomatic hip osteoarthritis. However, these medications manage symptoms rather than correct the underlying structural problem. Therefore, they are often used as part of a broader non-surgical treatment plan.

Corticosteroid Injections

A corticosteroid injection may be recommended when inflammation inside the hip joint continues to cause pain despite conservative treatment. The medication is delivered directly into the affected area to help reduce inflammation and improve comfort. Some patients experience relief for weeks or months, while others have a shorter response. The AAOS also reports moderate evidence that intra-articular corticosteroid injections can provide short-term pain relief in properly selected patients. Therefore, the decision to use a corticosteroid injection depends on your symptoms, imaging findings, and response to previous treatments.

Image-Guided Hip Injections

Image-guided hip injections use ultrasound or fluoroscopic imaging to accurately deliver medication into the hip joint. Because the hip joint lies deep beneath surrounding tissues, image guidance improves injection precision. Accurate placement helps ensure the medication reaches the intended area. In addition to relieving pain, the injection can help confirm whether the hip joint is the source of your symptoms. Image guidance also minimizes the risk of injecting surrounding tissues.

Assistive Devices

Using an assistive device can help reduce stress on your hip while it heals. Depending on your symptoms, Dr. Jarret Boroniec may recommend a cane or crutches for a short period. These devices can improve stability and make walking more comfortable. They may also help prevent unnecessary strain during painful flare-ups. The goal is to reduce stress on your hip while helping you move more comfortably during daily activities.

Ice and Heat Therapy

Ice and heat therapy can help manage hip pain at different stages of recovery. Usually, ice is used to reduce inflammation and swelling after activity or during a painful flare-up. In contrast, heat can help relax tight muscles and improve comfort before movement. Dr. Jarret Boroniec will explain when to use each method based on your symptoms. If used correctly, these simple treatments can provide additional relief as part of your overall care plan.

Which Hip Conditions May Require Hip Arthroscopy?

Hip arthroscopy may be recommended for conditions such as hip impingement (FAI), labral tears, loose bodies, cartilage damage, and certain tendon or ligament injuries when non-surgical treatment does not provide lasting relief. Many of these hip disorders occur together, so hip arthroscopy often addresses multiple problems during a single procedure.

Here is how each hip condition can affect your hip joint and when hip arthroscopy may be considered:

Femoroacetabular Impingement (FAI)

Femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) develops when the bones of the hip do not fit together as smoothly as they should. As the joint moves, repeated contact can damage the labrum and cartilage over time. Many people notice groin pain during sports, squatting, or prolonged sitting. Because the underlying bone shape does not change on its own, symptoms may continue. In such cases, hip arthroscopy can reshape the bone and address damaged tissue through two or three small incisions around the hip while preserving the natural hip joint.

Hip Labral Tears

The labrum is a ring of cartilage that helps stabilize the hip joint and creates a secure seal around it. When it tears, everyday movements may cause clicking, catching, or a sensation of the hip giving way. Some labrum tears develop after an injury, while others result from repetitive stress or FAI. While many labral tears improve with conservative treatment, persistent symptoms may continue to interfere with daily activities. In these cases, hip arthroscopy may be recommended to repair or remove the damaged portion of the labrum and restore more comfortable hip function.

Loose Bodies

Loose bodies are small fragments of bone or cartilage that move freely inside the hip joint. Unlike many other hip conditions, they can cause symptoms that come and go depending on where the fragment moves. You may suddenly feel the hip catch, lock, or experience weakness or stop moving normally. As these fragments continue to move inside the joint, they may repeatedly interfere with normal hip motion. Because they cannot be removed through non-surgical treatment, the surgeon uses a small camera to see inside the hip joint and can precisely locate and remove the loose bodies.

Cartilage Damage

Healthy cartilage allows the hip joint to move smoothly with minimal friction. Once that surface is damaged, movement may become painful and uncomfortable. In many cases, the damage develops gradually because hip injuries such as femoroacetabular impingement (FAI), arthritis, hip dysplasia, or labral tears continue to place abnormal stress on the joint. Without addressing the underlying cause, the damaged area may continue to experience abnormal wear over time. Depending on the extent of the injury, hip arthroscopy can treat damaged cartilage while correcting the underlying problem.

Synovitis

Synovitis occurs when the lining of the hip joint becomes inflamed. This inflammation may cause pain, stiffness, and swelling that limit everyday activities. Many patients improve with medications or other conservative treatments. However, persistent inflammation may continue to irritate the joint despite these measures. In such cases, hip arthroscopy can remove inflamed tissue while also examining the joint for other conditions contributing to your symptoms.

Snapping Hip Syndrome

A snapping sensation in the hip is common and is not always a sign of a serious problem. In many cases, it is painless and does not require treatment. However, when the snapping is accompanied by pain, frequent catching, numbness, or difficulty with daily activities, it may indicate an underlying hip condition. If it persists despite these conservative measures, hip arthroscopy may be considered to address the underlying cause.

Although these conditions can be treated with hip arthroscopy, the diagnosis alone does not determine whether surgery is the right choice. Instead, the decision depends on whether your symptoms, physical examination findings, and imaging all point to the same source of pain. Dr. Jarret Boroniec carefully correlates these findings rather than relying on MRI or X-ray alone during evaluation, since imaging abnormalities do not always cause symptoms.

He also considers how your condition affects your daily activities, work, sports, and long-term hip function before recommending surgery. If your pain can be managed successfully without an operation, conservative treatment is the preferred approach. However, when the underlying structural problem continues to cause pain and restrict movement despite appropriate non-surgical care, hip arthroscopy may provide lasting relief. This careful decision-making process helps ensure the recommended procedure addresses the underlying cause of your symptoms rather than simply treating the pain. If your symptoms persist despite conservative care, schedule an appointment with Dr. Jarret Boroniec.

When Should You Get a Second Opinion?

You should get a second opinion when your diagnosis is unclear, surgery has been recommended, or your symptoms continue despite treatment. Another specialist may confirm the cause of your symptoms, discuss alternative treatment options, and help you make a more informed decision. In fact, a large study of nearly 6,800 patient-initiated second opinions found that the consulting specialist changed the treatment recommendation in 37.4% of cases and the diagnosis in 14.8% of cases.

Our hip preservation specialist, Dr. Jarret Boroniec, uses the following approach to determine whether your diagnosis and treatment plan accurately address the underlying cause of your symptoms:

• Complete Case Review: Reviews your previous diagnosis, treatment history, and response to conservative care before recommending the next step.
• Independent Clinical Assessment: Provides an unbiased opinion based on your current symptoms rather than relying solely on previous recommendations.
• Precise Pain Source Identification: Determines which structure inside the hip is responsible for your symptoms.
• Treatment Gap Analysis: Evaluates whether additional non-surgical treatments may still help relieve your symptoms.
• Long-Term Function Planning: Recommends the treatment that best aligns with your lifestyle, activity level, and long-term hip health.
• Shared Treatment Decisions: Discusses the benefits, risks, and expected outcomes of each available treatment option.

Can Dr. Jarret Boroniec Help if Previous Treatment Failed?

Yes, Dr. Jarret Boroniec can help if previous treatment has not relieved your hip pain or restored normal function. He carefully re-evaluates your condition to determine why previous treatment has not provided relief or if another hip condition or structural problem is contributing to your ongoing symptoms. After determining the underlying cause, he recommends the treatment that best matches your diagnosis, symptoms, and long-term goals.

What Results Should You Expect After Surgery?

Most patients experience significant pain relief and improved hip function after hip arthroscopy. A 2024 systematic review found that nearly 80% of patients returned to the same or higher level of sport after hip arthroscopy for FAI. Another systematic review found that patients experienced significant improvements in pain, hip function, quality of life, and return to sport, with 75.6% to 98% returning to the same or higher level of athletic participation after surgery.

Similarly, a meta-analysis of 15 studies involving 823 athletes reported that 88.3% returned to sport after hip arthroscopy, while 85.3% returned to their pre-injury level. The review also found low complication rates and consistent improvements in patient-reported outcomes. Although these studies report favorable outcomes, recovery varies from person to person. Therefore, following your rehabilitation program and activity restrictions is essential to optimize healing and restore hip function.

Common Patient Scenarios

Hip problems do not always improve as expected, and symptoms can sometimes persist or return even after treatment. Here are some common situations patients may face:

I Already Had Hip Arthroscopy, but My Hip Symptoms Have Returned

Symptoms that return after a previous hip arthroscopy may have several possible causes. Some patients may develop recurrent impingement, new tissue damage, scar tissue, or another problem affecting the joint. Determining what has changed since the first procedure is important before deciding whether additional treatment or revision surgery may be appropriate.

My Hip Pain Is Getting Worse When I Walk, and I’m Worried I May Eventually Need Surgery

Worsening hip pain with walking does not necessarily mean surgery will be required. The decision depends on the underlying condition, the extent of joint damage, and how symptoms respond to nonsurgical treatment. Surgery is generally considered when a treatable structural problem continues to cause significant symptoms despite appropriate conservative care.

I Have More Than One Problem in My Hip, and I’m Worried One Surgery Won’t Address Everything

Hip conditions can occur together, making surgical planning more complex. For example, structural abnormalities may coexist with damage to cartilage or other tissues. In these cases, surgery may need to address each problem contributing to the patient’s symptoms rather than treating only one area of the hip.

My Hip Flexor Injury Is Taking Longer to Improve Than I Expected

Recovery from a hip flexor injury can vary depending on the severity of the strain and the demands placed on the injured tissue. When symptoms continue beyond the expected recovery period or when function remains limited, further evaluation may be needed. It can help determine whether the injury is more significant than initially suspected or if another hip condition is contributing to the symptoms.

Book Your Appointment With Dr. Jarret Boroniec for Expert Hip Arthroscopy Care! 

Persistent hip pain can make walking, exercising, working, and even simple daily activities increasingly difficult. Many people assume they simply have to live with the discomfort or that hip replacement is their only option, but that is not always true. In reality, many hip conditions can be treated successfully without hip replacement when they are diagnosed early.

At Total Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, Dr. Jarret Boroniec provides specialized care for patients who want to preserve their natural hip and maintain an active lifestyle. From active adults to competitive athletes, he provides advanced care for a wide range of hip conditions using both conservative treatment and minimally invasive hip arthroscopy. Call 855-321-6784 or visit our clinic to schedule your consultation.

FAQs